• This topic has 3 replies, 3 voices, and was last updated 5 days ago by KYLE FLEMING.
Viewing 4 posts - 1 through 4 (of 4 total)

2120 Chapter 10 Discussion


  • Avatar photo
    Nick Palmisano
    Keymaster
    Nick Palmisano

    Purpose

    This activity is designed to improve and develop a better understanding of the Module’s topics. The activity incorporates both critical thinking and the application for the Fire Officer.

    Discussion Post Instructions:

    Review Chapter 10 in your textbook.
    Review Module 10’s Learning Resources unit and slides.
    Post your response to the Discussion Forum.

    Discussion

    Why might prestressed concrete systems be more vulnerable to failure than ordinary reinforced concrete? 

    Discussion Post Requirements

    Your initial post must be a minimum of 100 words.

    You must respond to at least two of your classmates. Each response must be a minimum of 50 words.

    All discussion postings must be typed directly into the discussion forum.

    #15718

    jonathan shadoin
    Participant
    jonathan shadoin

    Pre-stressed concrete systems can be more vulnerable to failure than ordinary reinforced concrete due to their reliance on high tension forces and the integrity of pre-stressed tendons. Unlike conventional reinforced concrete, which distributes loads more gradually, pre-stressed concrete relies on carefully applied compressive forces to counteract tensile stresses. If these forces are disrupted due to tendon corrosion, improper tensioning, or sudden overloading the entire system can fail abruptly. Additionally, pre stressed concrete is more sensitive to cracking, as minor defects can lead to a loss of pre-stress and a rapid reduction in structural integrity. Proper design, maintenance, and quality control are essential to mitigate these risks.

    #20244

    KYLE FLEMING
    Participant
    KYLE FLEMING

    Due to relying on high-tension steel strands to maintain their structural integrity, prestressed concrete systems may be more vulnerable to failure than ordinary reinforced concrete in fire conditions. When exposed to heat, these steel tendons lose strength and can rapidly relax or snap, causing sudden and complete failure of the concrete element. Unlike ordinary reinforced concrete, which may fail gradually and provide warning signs, prestressed systems can collapse without visible indicators.

    Additionally, the tensioned steel is often under extreme stress, and once compromised by heat, the stored energy can be released violently. This makes prestressed concrete particularly dangerous for firefighters operating beneath or near these elements during a fire.

    #20330

    KYLE FLEMING
    Participant
    KYLE FLEMING

    Thank you DE Ed Shadoin for your educated response. I agree. Pre-stressed concrete systems are more vulnerable to sudden failure because they rely on high-tension tendons to maintain strength. If these tendons are damaged by corrosion, fire, or improper tensioning, the structure can fail abruptly. Unlike traditional reinforced concrete, which allows more gradual failure, pre-stressed systems are less forgiving. Even minor cracks can lead to a loss of pre-stress and rapid structural compromise. Proper design and maintenance are critical to ensure safety.

    #20331
Viewing 4 posts - 1 through 4 (of 4 total)

You must be logged in to reply to this topic.